INTRODUCTION
Type II Diabetes patients usually associates with hyperlipoidemia.
In this study, Chinese lipid-lowering medicine Xuezhikang was employed
to identify its influence on the levels of blood sugar and lipid.
PATIENTS
AND METHODS
Selection
of Patients
Patients came from internal medicine division, health and
rehabilitation division, Chinese medicine division and inpatient
division of the hospital. According to diabetes clinical standards
stipulated by diabetes expert committee of WHO, patients with ketoacidosis
and serious diseases of heart, liver, kidney and gallbladder were
excluded. Those type II diabetes patients, without any endocrinosis
or not taking any hypoglycemic agent and antilipemic agent within
a month, met one or more of the following requirements were chosen
as target patients: (1) Serum TC ³ 5.95 mmol/L (³ 300mg/dl);
(2) TG ³ 2.25 mmol/L (³ 200 mg/dl); (3) HDL-C £
1.04 mmol/L ( £ 40 mg/dl) in male and £ 1.16 mmol/L
(4.5 mg/dL ) in female.
All
parameters of the patients in above three group meet comparison
principles.
See Table I.
Group
|
Diagnose
|
Cases
|
Age
|
MBI
|
|
|
Male
|
Female
|
(X
± S)
|
(X
± S)
|
Group
1
|
DHL
*
|
88
|
52
|
47.5
± 11.0
|
23.25
± 5.23
|
Group
2
|
Hyperlipoidemia
|
72
|
48
|
46.7
± 11.5
|
22.86
± 5.36
|
Group
3
|
DNL*
|
65
|
42
|
46.9
± 12.3
|
23.17
± 6.46
|
Note:
DHL stands for diabetes with hyperlipoidemia; DNL stands for
diabetes with normal lipid level.
In every t-test, P > 0.05. |
Observational Method
After 2 weeks of diet education and promotion activities, patients
in each group took Xuezhikang capsules 0.6 g a time (two capsules),
twice a day. Diabetes patients in group 1 and 3 also took hypoglycemic
agent Glipizide together with melbine or a-glycosidase inhibitor
with their dosage adjusted according to blood sugar level. After
8 weeks of treatment, the curative effect was evaluated. Before
and after the treatment, the concentration of serum TC, TG, HDL-C,
AS (= TC/HDL-C), FBG and 2h-PG of patients in every group were measured
at the same time.
Criteria
for Effect
According
to the Guiding Standards (Draft Document) of Clinical Application
of New Medicines stipulated by the Ministry of Public Health in
1993, the criteria of curative effect is as the following:
- Highly
effective
TC reduction ³ 20% or TG reduction ³ 40%, or HDL-C increase
³ 10 mg/dL
(0.26 mmol/L), AS decrease ³ 20%.
- Effective
TC reduction by 10% ~ 20%, or TG reduction by 20% ~ 40%, or HDL-C
increase by
4 ~ 10 mg/dL (0.1 ~ 0.25 mmol/L), AS decrease by 10% ~ 20%.
- Ineffective
It can not reach any one of the above level.
Criteria
for curative effect on blood sugar are:
- Highly
effective
FBG < 7.2 mmol/L, IAPG < 8.3 mmol/L.
- Effective
FBG < 8.3 mmol/L, 2hPG < 10.0 mmol/L.
- Ineffective
No improvement occurs in clinical symptoms and every lab test
cannot meet the above standard.
RESULTS
Examinations
were carried out to patients in the three groups treated by Xuezhikang
for 8 weeks and 48 cases of type II diabetes patients who only took
sugar-reduction agent but no antilipemic agent in the past were
chosen randomly. Comparable parameters such as average age, physique
index and treatment time were set for comparison. Statistic analysis
proved that Xuezhikang could not only regulate blood lipid to normal
range, but also obviously reduced blood sugar in conjunction with
hypoglycemic agent.
Effects
on Blood Sugar of Type II Diabetes Patients
After
8 weeks treatment, FBG and 2h-PG level of group 1 and group 3 patients
dropped by 1.08mmol/L, 1.74mmol/L and 1.44mmol/L, 2.28mmol/L respectively,
which accounted for 12.05%, 16.0% and 16.0%, 20.9% correspondingly,
all with very significant difference
(P <0.001). Although the decreases of FBG and 2h-PG in group
3 were higher than that of group 1, the difference was not significant
in statistics (P > 0.05).
Simultaneous
administration of Xuezhikang with hypoglycemic agent for diabetes
patients will not influence the effectiveness of hypoglycemic agents,
on the contrary, it facilitates the decline of blood sugar. It is
worth noting here that there were great differences on blood sugar
reduction of those patients that only take pure hypoglycemic agent
in the past compared with that in group 1 and group 3 (P < 0.05).
The total efficacy of FBG and 2h-PG were 85.4%, 92.5%, 78.6% and
74.3%, 76.6%, 64.8% respectively. Whereas no statistic difference
exists in efficacy data between group 1 and group 3. The findings
indicated that better curative effects could be expected when hypoglycemic
agent was taken with antilipemic agent regardless of the lipid level
being high or normal in diabetes patients.
(See Table II)
Table
II. Change of blood sugar and lipid levels 8 weeks after Xuezhikang
treatment |
|
|
Group
1
|
Group 2
|
Group
3
|
|
|
(n=140)
|
p
|
(x=120)
|
p
|
(n=107)
|
p
|
TC |
BT*
(mmol/L)
AT* (mmol/L)
Change Rate(%) |
6.97
±0.76
5.02± 0.65
-1.95 (27.9)
|
<
0.001
|
6.89±0.87
4.85±0.72
-2.04(29.6)
|
<
0.001
|
1.95
± 0.35
1.89± 0.46
-0.06 (3.1)
|
<0.001
|
TG |
BT
(mmol/L)
AT (mmol/L)
Change Rate(%) |
3.06
± 0.84
1.96 ± 1.05
-1.10 (35.9)
|
<
0.001
|
2.87
±1.02
1.89± 0.87
-0.96(34.1)
|
<
0.001
|
1.95
± 0.35
1.89± 0.46
-0.06 (3.1)
|
<0.001
|
HDL-C |
BT
(mmol/L)
AT (mmol/L)
Change Rate(%) |
0.96
± 0.25
1.18 ± 0.32
+0.22(23.0)
|
<
0.001
|
0.98
±0.35
1.17± 0.46
+0.19(19.0)
|
<
0.001
|
1.28
± 0.46
1.38± 0.56
+0.10 (8.0)
|
<0.001
|
AS |
BT
(mmol/L)
AT (mmol/L)
Change Rate(%) |
5.95
± 0.79
3.86 ± 0.84
-2.09 (35.1)
|
<
0.001
|
6.01
± 0.85
4.09 ± 0.90
-1.92(31.9)
|
<
0.001
|
3.46
± 0.67
3.19 ± 0.58
-0.27 (7.8)
|
<0.001
|
FBG |
BT
(mmol/L)
AT (mmol/L)
Change Rate(%) |
8.96
± 1.08
7.88 ± 1.13
-1.08(12.05)
|
<
0.001
|
5.06
± 1.32
5.12 ± 1.25
+0.06 (1.1)
|
<
0.001
|
9.01
± 1.32
7.57 ± 1.45
-1.44 (16.0)
|
<0.001
|
2h-PG |
BT
(mmol/L)
AT (mmol/L)
Change Rate(%) |
10.86
±2.06
9.12 ± 2.15
-1.74 (16.0)
|
<
0.001
|
5.87
± 1.56
5.82 ± 1.70
-0.05 (0.8)
|
<
0.001
|
10.90
± 1.84
8.62 ± 2.03
-2.28 (20.9)
|
<0.001
|
Note:
BT stands for before treatment and AT stands for after treatment. |
Effects of Xuezhikang on reducing lipid level
There
were significant change of various lipid levels in patients of group
1 and group 2 after the treatment (P < 0.001). TC fell by 27.9%
in group 1 and 29.6% in group 3. TG drops by 35.9% in group1 and
34.1% in group 3. And HDL-C level went up 23.0% in group1 and 19.0%
in group three. Whereas AS decreased by 35.1% in group 1 and 31.9%
in group 3. The data of group 3 before and after the treatment showed
no difference in terms of statistics ( P > 0.05). The efficacy
of TC reduction reached by 93.6% in group 1 and 95.0% in group 2;
TG reduction by 90.0% in group 1 and 90.8% in group 2; HDL-C elevation
by 84.3% in group 1 and 85.8% in group 2; AS decrease by 91.5% in
group 1 and 91.7% in group 2. However, there was no clear difference
of the same index between the two groups (P > 0.05). (See Table
III)
DISCUSSION
Primary
investigations indicated that 53.8 percent (140/260) of type II
diabetes patients in Xinjiang Autonomous Region have higher TC,
TG and lower HDL-C level than that of common people. And type II
diabetes patients possess 2~ 3 times risks of getting cardiocerebrovascular
syndromes. Much better curative effects occur when type II diabetes
patients with higher lipid level take hypoglycemic agent coupled
with Xuezhikang compared with past practice that patients take only
hypoglycemic medicine with other conditions the same (P < 0.05).
After the treatment, the total efficacy of FBG reduction of patients
with normal lipid level is higher than diabetes patients with hyperlipoidemia
(P< 0.05). Whereas no difference occurs in efficacy of 2h-PG
data between two groups
(P > 0.05).
Xuezhikang
contains HMG-CoA reductase inhibitor and many active components
such as unsaturated fatty acids and amino acid necessary for human
being. It is an ideal medicine to regulate lipid level. It is found
from multi-group curative effect analysis that pure administration
of hypoglycemic medicine cannot lead to desired cure, nor can it
decrease potential risk of cardiocerebrovascular diseases for diabetes
patients. It is particularly true for diabetes patients with high
levels TC, TG and low level of HDL-C, as they are major factors
affecting curative effects of hypoglycemic medicine. However, Xuezhikang
is able to suppress TG and synthesis of fatty acids and accelerate
lipometabolism, thus promoting activity of b cells of pancreas islet
and prodcing more insulin. In addition, Xuezhikang can cut down
lipid level and improve the imbalance among various ingredients.
In particular, the decline of AS(TC/HDL-C) can enhance the sensitivity
of surrounding tissue to insulin, consequently help to lower blood
sugar level. Thus, it is regarded that simultaneous treatment on
both blood sugar and lipid is a reasonable cure method for diabetes
patients coupled with hyperlipoidemia. And small amount of Xuezhikang
will do no harm but good for normal diabetes patients when treated
with hypoglycemic medicine.
Table
III. Curative effects on blood sugar and lipid level of each
group treated by Xuezhikang for 8 weeks |
|
|
Group
1
|
Group 2
|
Group
3
|
|
|
(n=140)
|
(x=120)
|
p
|
(n=107)
|
p
|
TC |
Highly
effective (%)
Effective (%)
Total efficacy (%) |
112
(80.0)
19 (13.6)
131 (93.6)
|
98(81.7)
16(13.3)
114(95.0)
|
>0.05
|
|
|
TG |
Highly
effective (%)
Effective (%)
Total efficacy (%) |
94(67.1)
32(22.9)
126(90.0)
|
61
(50.8)
48 (40.0)
109(90.8)
|
>0.05
|
|
|
HDL-C |
Highly
effective (%)
Effective (%)
Total efficacy (%) |
74(52.9)
44(31.4)
118(84.3)
|
67
(55.8)
36 (30.0)
103(85.8)
|
>0.05
|
|
|
AS |
Highly
effective (%)
Effective (%)
Total efficacy (%) |
96(68.6)
32(22.9)
128(91.5)
|
84
(70.0)
26 (21.7)
118(91.7)
|
>0.05
|
|
|
FBG |
Highly
effective (%)
Effective (%)
Total efficacy (%)) |
40(28.6)
73(58.1)
119(85.4)
|
|
|
32
(29.9)
67 (59.6)
99 (92.5)
|
<0.05
|
2h-PG |
Highly
effective (%)
Effective (%)
Total efficacy (%) |
15(10.7)
89(63.6)
104(74.3)
|
|
|
13
(12.1)
69 (64.5)
82 (76.6)
|
<0.05
|
|