ABSTRACT
[Objective]:
80 patients with hyperlipidemia were randomly divided into group
of Xuezhikang and ZOCOR. TC and TG decreased similarly in both groups,
but the effect on LDL-c lowering in ZOCOR group is better than that
of Xuezhikang group; the effect of increasing HDL-c in ZOCOR group
is better than that of Xuezhikang group, but the increased ratio
of two groups has no notable difference. During this trial all the
patients in both groups had no obvious side effects observed.
[Key Words]: Xuezhikang, ZOCOR , Hyperlipidemia
INTRODUCTION
Xuezhikang, the initial domestically produced medicine in adjusting
lipids, which contains chiefly HMG-CoA reductase inhibitor. This
paper intends to further study the adjusting lipids action of Xuezhikang,
and compares with that of ZOCOR.
CASES AND METHOD
Standard
of Diagnosis: TC=5.70mmol/L, and/or TG=2.36mmol/L, or LDL-C=3.36mmol/L,
and/or HDL-C=1.57mmol/L in male, =1.82mmol/L in female.
Case's Standard: The adult patients with hyperlipidemia, in outpatient
clinic (OPD) or on admission, with primary diagnosed of hyperlipidemia
and never received any treatment before, who were compatible with
the standard being selected randomly in two groups of Xuezhikang
and ZOCOR. The general conduction and level of lipid are basically
similar in two groups (as shown in Table I.)
|
Xuezhikang
Group
|
ZOCOR
Group
|
Case
(Male/Female) |
47
(19/28)
|
33
(14/19)
|
Age
(y)* |
57.67±9.69
|
57.58±8.74
|
With
HD(c) |
57.58±8.74
|
8
|
With
CHD(c) |
7
|
2
|
Blood
lipid (X±SD mmol/L)* |
|
|
TC |
6.48±1.03
|
6.47±0.93
|
TG |
2.71±1.16
|
2.80±1.05
|
HDL-C |
0.94±0.35
|
0.96±0.38
|
LDL-C |
4.33±0.97
|
4.04±0.66
|
*
P>0.05, comparison between the two groups |
Standard of Exclusion:
During the last 6 months, Patients had suffered from myocardial
infarction, stroke, severe trauma or major surgery, gravida and
women in lactation;
Patients suffered from nephrotic syndrome, hypothyroidism, acute
or chronic hepatobiliary disorders, diabetes mellitus (DM) or gout;
Patients has hyperlipemia induced by drugs (Such as phenothiazine,
beta-blocking agent, adrenocortical steroid, some kinds of contraceptive
and etc.);
Complicated with other sever or metal diseases;
Patients with irritability physique or did not obey the rule of
medication, therefore influenced its effect, or the clinical materials
are insufficient to judge its safety.
Method
The
patients took Xuezhikang 0.6g each time, twice a day in Xuezhikang
group, and Zocor 10mg once in the evening. Before and 4 weeks after
the treatment, took samples of venous blood on an empty stomach
respectively in the morning, and checked blood lipid, hepatic and
renal function and blood sugar. During medication the patients were
asked to maintain their dietary habits and living styles as before.
Drugs that are not interfering with blood lipid metabolism for hypertension
or CHD may be continued.
Criteria
of Assay: take the enzyme reagent and method to assay directly the
level of serum TC, TG, HDL-C and LDL-C, or hepatic and renal function
and blood sugar.
Statistical
Processing: paired t test, cpd analysis and chi-square test.
Standard
of Judgement of Curative Effect: According to the "Clinical
Research Guidance Principle on Drug" by the Ministry of Health
July in 1993. (1) Evident Effects: Achieved the following arbitrary
items: TC decreased by =20%; TG decreased by=40%; HDL-C increased
by=0.26mmol/L respectively. (2) Effective: TC decreased by =10%-29%;
TG decreased by=20%-39%; HDL-C increased by=0.104-0.25mmol/L. (3)
Invalid: did not reach the above-mentioned standard. (4) Worsen,
achieved the following arbitrary items: TC increased by=10%; HDL-C
decreased by=0.104mmol/L.
RESULTS
After
4-week treatment, there are valuable reducing TC,TG and increasing
HDL-c in both groups, but the total effect in increasing HDL-C with
Xuezhikang is lower than that of ZOCOR(P<0.05) (as shown in Table
II).
Table
II. Comparison of effect in adjusting blood lipid |
|
|
Case
|
Evidently
Effective
|
Effective
|
No
Effective
|
Worsen
|
n
|
Total
Effective (%)
|
TC* |
Xuezhikang
|
47
|
28
|
11
|
6
|
2
|
39
|
82.98
|
|
Zocor
|
33
|
17
|
13
|
2
|
1
|
30
|
90.91
|
TG** |
Xuezhikang
|
45
|
5
|
13
|
21
|
6
|
18
|
40.00
|
|
Zocor
|
32
|
1
|
13
|
17
|
1
|
14
|
43.75
|
HDL*** |
Xuezhikang
|
47
|
5
|
14
|
23
|
5
|
19
|
40.43
|
|
Zocor
|
33
|
9
|
12
|
8
|
4
|
21
|
63.63
|
*u=0.31,
p>0.05; **u=0.25, p>0.05; ***u=1.98, p>0.05 |
After 4-week treatment, from the aspect of range of lowering, there
are no notable differences in reducing TC and TG in both groups,
except LDL-C decreased by Xuezhikang is better than that of ZOCOR
(P<0.01). There is no notable difference in the range of increasing
HDL-C in both groups (as shown in Table III.).
Table
III. Comparison of level of blood lipid between pre-treatment
and post-treatment (X±SD mmol/L) |
|
Group
|
Pre-treatment
|
Post-Treatment
|
Difference(%)*
|
P
Value
|
TC |
Xuezhikang |
6.48±1.03
|
5.05±0.98
|
1.48±1.15(22.84)
|
0.000
|
|
Zocor |
6.47±0.93
|
5.12±0.62
|
1.35±0.09(22.87)
|
0.000
|
TG |
Xuezhikang |
2.71±1.16
|
2.40±0.91
|
0.36±1.06(13.28)
|
0.028
|
|
Zocor |
2.28±1.05
|
2.54±0.82
|
0.29±0.62(10.36)
|
0.032
|
HDL-C
|
Xuezhikang |
0.94±0.35
|
1.00±0.31
|
-0.06±0.16(-6.38)
|
0.013
|
|
Zocor |
0.96±0.38
|
1.13±0.47
|
-0.17±0.35(17.71)
|
0.008
|
LDL-C |
Xuezhikang |
4.33±0.97
|
3.03±0.90
|
1.46±1.15(33.72)
|
0.000
|
|
Zocor |
4.04±0.66
|
3.14±0.75
|
0.90±0.66(22.28)
|
0.000
|
The
result of metabolic variable compared between pretreatment and
post treatment : TC:u=0.5, P>0.05; TG:u=0.3, P>0.05; HDL-C:u=1.67
,P>0.05; LDL-C:u=2.80, P<0.01, by U test respectively. |
For any level of TG and HDL-C, the curing effect is the most significant
when it is >2.27mmol/L and =0.91mmol/L respectively (Table IV).
Table
IV. Effective of different level of TG and HDL-C between groups(X±SDdmmol/L) |
|
|
Xuezhikang
|
Zocor
|
|
Lipid
Level
|
Case
|
Pre-
|
Post-
|
P
|
Case
|
Pre-
|
Post-
|
P
|
TG |
I
|
18
|
1.64±0.45
|
1.87±0.93
|
0.226
|
11
|
1.79±0.31
|
1.92±1.72
|
0.460
|
|
II
|
15
|
2.95±0.30
|
2.49±0.56
|
0.003
|
10
|
2.82±0.34
|
2.49±0.33
|
0.049
|
|
III
|
12
|
4.23±0.58
|
3.18±0.60
|
0.020
|
10
|
4.08±0.51
|
3.38±0.40
|
0.004
|
HDL-C
|
I
|
8
|
1.49±0.35
|
1.42±0.38
|
0.313
|
6
|
1.55±0.40
|
1.65±0.66
|
0.590
|
|
II
|
13
|
1.03±0.06
|
1.06±0.14
|
0.528
|
10
|
1.07±0.05
|
1.11±0.30
|
0.660
|
|
III
|
26
|
0.70±0.14
|
0.83±0.18
|
0.000
|
17
|
0.68±0.15
|
0.95±0.34
|
0.004
|
* TG I: =2.26mmol/L, II 2.27-3.38mmol/L, III =3.39mmol/L;
HDL-C: I =1.17mmol/L, II 1.16-0.92mmol/L, III =0.91mmol/L. |
All
patients had no evident side effects after 4-week treatment, and
no significant difference of blood sugar before and after treatment
observed (P>0.05).
DISCUSSION
The
lipid infiltration theory has a close relationship with the development
of atherosclerosis (AS). Hyperlipidemia is one of the major risk
factors for coronary heart disease (CHD). TC, TG and LDL-C decrease,
HDL-C increases, and lipid level maintains on normal level well
benefit to inhibit AS and lowing the morbidity and mortality associated
with CHD. For the treatment of hyperlipemia, is stressed upon comprehensive
therapy, supplement with drugs on the basis of dietary adjustment
and proper exercises is very important. At present, most of the
medicines in adjusting lipid for clinical treatment are imported,
and the medicines of domestic production are rather less satisfied
in its effect. But Xuezhikang capsule, used in this experiment is
produced and refined from red yeast rice provided by the WBL Peking
University Biotech Co.Ltd., and the chief components is the HMG-CoA
reductase inhibitor, multiple kinds of essential amino acids and
unsaturated fatty acids and polysaccharides and etc. that the human
body needs. It reduces biosynthesis of TC, through feedback adjustment,
and increased activity of receptor of LDL on the surface of liver
cell and accelerated the removal of LDL[3]. The evident effect and
ideal safety with ZOCOR have been confirmed by extensive clinical
staffs. The chief effective composition of ZOCOR is also due to
contains HMG-COA reductase inhibitor [4,5].
The
results in this trial indicated that, after taking Xuezhikang for
4 weeks, actions in reducing TC, TG, LDL-C and increasing HDL-c
were remarkable and no side effects occurred, and the similar results
were seen in treatment with Zocor. The effective rate in increasing
HDL-C, Zocor was better than Xuezhikang(P<0.05), but no significant
difference on the range of increasing its level of content. It seemed
that the level of TG reduced, Xuezhikang was little better than
Zocor, but there was no significant difference in both groups. It
is probably that owing to Xuezhikang included multiple kinds of
essential amino acid and unsaturated fatty acids.
At
same time, the results indicated that the higher level of TG and
the lower level of HDL-C were, the more significant effective by
Xuezhikang, which is identical with the result observed by Wang
Junxian et al [1].
It
was reported: after 8-week treated with Xuezhikang the TG decreased
by 28.1-36.4% and HDL-C increased by 19.6%[1,2], while in this trial,
TG decreased by 13.28% and HDL-C increased by 6.38%, and total effects
in adjusting lipids in both groups are significant different as
compared with relevant reports. Through analysis of the result we
obtained, considered that possibly it related with the short-term
treatment, and without restrict dietary control and lack of physical
exercises. Whether any other reason influenced its effect, still
requires further observation.
In
summary, we suggest that Xuezhikang is an effective and well-tolerated
lipid-adjusting medicine of domestic production, which possess the
function to regulating the disorder of lipid metabolism.
REFERENCES
1
.
|
Wang
Junxian, Lu Zongliang, Chi Jiamin,et al. Treatment of Hyperlipidemia
with Xuezhikang capsule. Chin J Exper Trad Med Formula 1995;
1(1): 1~5
|
2.
|
Kou
W, Lu Z, Guo Y, et al. Clinical Effect of Primary hyperlipidemia
with Xuezhikang. Chin J Intern Med, 1997,36(8), 529-531
|
3.
|
Brown
MS,Godldstein JL.A receptor-mediated pathway for ence with
simvatatin.Drug Invest. cholest erol homeostasis Science,1993;5:135-140
1986,232:34
|
4.
|
Todd
PA,Goa KL.Sim-vatatin:A review of its pharmaco-logical properlies
and therapeutic p Otentianl for hypercholesterolemia.Druges.1990;40:583-607
|
5.
|
Boccuzzi
ST,Keegan ME,Hirsch IJ,el.al.Long-term experi-ence with simvatatin.Drug
Invest.1993;5:135-140
|
|